ISSN online: 2221-1616

Bulletin of the Institute of Sociology (Vestnik instituta sotziologii)

Research Article

Gennady V. Kosov Doctor of Political Science, Professor,
Sevastopol State University, Sevastopol, Russia
kossov1@yandex.ru
ORCID ID=0000-0002-1422-895X
Olga V. Yarmak Doctor of Sociology
Sevastopol State University, Sevastopol, Russia
olga_yarmak@inbox.ru
ORCID ID=0000-0002-5025-9112
Lyudmila N. Garas Candidate of Philosophy, Associate professor,
Sevastopol State University, Sevastopol, Russia
garas_ln@mail.ru
ORCID ID=0000-0002-0391-652X
Galicia and Donbass as Ideal models of regional identity: sociocultural roots of the confrontation between Western and Eastern Ukraine.
Vestnik instituta sotziologii. 2024. Vol. 15. No. 3. P. 107-134

The study was carried out within the framework of the project by the RSF no. 23-28-01684 “Features of the perception of state transit in the regions of post-Ukraine”.

Дата поступления статьи: 06.08.2024
Topic: Regional Identity in Russia and Abroad

For citation:
Kosov G. V., Yarmak O. V., Garas L. N. Galicia and Donbass as Ideal models of regional identity: sociocultural roots of the confrontation between Western and Eastern Ukraine. Vestnik instituta sotziologii. 2024. Vol. 15. No. 3. P. 107-134
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19181/vis.2024.15.3.7. EDN: MFHOTB



Abstract

The article examines ideal models of regional identity in Ukraine – Galicia and Donbass. It is emphasised that Ukraine, having become a sovereign state and appeared on the political map of the world in 1991, faced the problem of a pronounced mosaic of regions. Individual regions were included in Ukraine already formed as distinctive entities with stable features of culture and way of life of the population. The authors emphasise that on the territory of Ukraine there coexisted a number of territorial complexes that were rather weakly connected with each other, and their subordination to various states due to frequent changes in borders determined their complex interaction. The processes of changing the political affiliation of regions actualise the identification issue, and identity in such conditions turns into a kind of demiurge of reality and can act as the main, and sometimes the only source of meanings. The declaration of independence by Ukraine actualised historically formed contradictions, previously existing mainly latently. The article proves the existence of socio-cultural regions, unique ethno-territorial communities, creating a continuum with a clearly expressed dichotomy - Donbass and Galicia. Beginning from the first years of Ukraine's independence, the image of the new independent country as a great European power, the formation of which has always been hindered and continues to be hindered by Russia, was actively introduced into the consciousness of citizens. That is, a project was promoted based on Galician nationalism (with an emphatically Russophobic basis) and the concept of the "titular Ukrainian nation". In turn, regionalist sentiments in the Eastern Ukraine showed that regional identity can have great potential for the social integration of citizens. Since the 1990s, Donbass has often acted as an object of deliberate "otherness" on the part of the Ukrainian political and cultural elite, which was a contrasting background in the context of the practices of national construction in Ukraine. The authors conclude that the formation of Ukrainian national identity was carried out in a very contradictory manner and was characterised by a clear dominance of regional identity in the Eastern Ukraine against the background of the total promotion of the Galician project, and since 2014, its promotion has been carried out by armed means. However, the violent desire to level the regional identity of the inhabitants of the Eastern Ukraine launched the process of secession of the region - the self-proclamation of the DPR and LPR and their subsequent inclusion in the Russian Federation in 2022.

Keywords

regional identity, Ukraine, Russia, Donbass, Galicia

References
  1. Achkasov V. A. Ethnic and national identity in the modern world. Vestnik SPbGU. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2012: 1: 85–91 (in Russ.). EDN: OQRILX.
  2. Baranov A. V. Directions and methods of identity construction in conditions of armed conflict (based on the materials of the Donetsk and Lugansk people's republics). In Political Space and Social Time: The Right of Might vs. the Power of Law. Ed. by T. A. Senyushkinoj. Simferopol, Arial, 2023: 56–61 (in Russ.). EDN: OJZSXA.
  3. Baranov A. V. Contemporary identities's conflict in Ukraine: its imfluence on social disintegration. Nacionalnaya bezopasnost i strategicheskoe planirovanie, 2015: 4: 18–24 (in Russ.). EDN: VCHDQF.
  4. Vavilov A. Current political manifestations of regionalism in the context of the power crisis in Ukraine. International Trends. Mezhdunarodnye process, 2021: 19(2): 85–104 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.17994/IT.2021.19.2.65.5; EDN: IBBICM.
  5. Valevskij O. Topical issues in modern conditions of state policy of identity. Naukovi perspektivi, 2023: 9(39): 52–65 (in Ukr.). DOI: 10.52058/2708-7530-2023-9(39)-52-65. 
  6. Vermenich Ya. V. Donbas in the context of boderlandstheories: socio-humanitarian analysis. Ukrayinskij istorichnij zhurnal, 2015: 1: 108–134 (in Ukr.).
  7. Vermenich Ya. V. Regionalism in Ukraine as a cultural phenomenon. Izvestiya Rossijskoj akademii nauk. Ser. geograficheskaya, 2014: 1: 28–35 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.15356/0373-2444-2014-1-28-35; EDN: RWTVFF.
  8. Vermenich Ya. V. Territorial identity of the Ukrainian border region: historical origins and geopolitical influences. Ed. by V. A. Smolij. Kiev, Institut istoriyi Ukrayini, 2019: 367 (in Ukr.).
  9. Gnatyuk O. M. Hierarchical structure of spatial identity of the Ukrainian population. Ekonomichna ta socialna geografiya, 2012: 65: 242–250 (in Ukr.).
  10. Gricaj E., Nikolko M. Ukraina: nacionalnaya identichnost v zerkale Drugogo [Ukraine: National Identity in the Mirror of the Other]. Vilnyus, EGU, 2009: 220 (in Russ.).
  11. Independence Day of Ukraine: the path to victory, the identity and value of the state against the background of war. Accessed 16.06.2024. URL: https://dif.org.ua/article/den-nezalezhnosti-ukraini-shlyakh-do-peremogi-identichnist-ta-tsinnist-derzhavi-na-tli-viyni#_Toc143506371 (in Ukr.).
  12. Dergachyov V. A. Raskalyonnye rubezhi [Hot Frontiers]. Odessa, Astroprint, 1998: 104 (in Russ.).
  13. Dnistryanskij M. S. Etnopolitichna geografiya Ukrayini: problemi teoriyi, metodologiyi, praktiki [Ethnopolitical geography of Ukraine: problems of theory, methodology, practice]. Lviv, Vid. centr LNU im. Ivana Franka, 2006: 490 (in Ukr.).
  14. Zhilcov S. S. The origins of contemporary ukrainian nationalism. Vestnik RUDN. Ser. Politologiya, 2014: 4: 21–36 (in Russ.). EDN: TAFSHF.
  15. Zhirun I. V. Formation of the Ukrainian Identity: Civic, Ethnic or PostColonial? Rossiya v sovremennom mire, 2021: 3: 145–164 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.31249/rsm/2021.03.09; EDN: BVHSRM.
  16. Zhurzhenko T. Yu. Rasshirenie Evropy i perspektivy «evropeizacii» ukrainsko-rossijskogo pogranichya [The expansion of Europe and the prospects for the "Europeanization" of the Ukrainian-Russian borderland]. Politiya, 2004: 2: 106–119 (in Russ.).
  17. Identity of citizens of Ukraine: trends of change (May 2023). Accessed 14.06.2024. URL: https://razumkov.org.ua/napriamky/sotsiologichni-doslidzhennia/identychnist-gromadian-ukrainy-tendentsii-zmin-traven-2023r. (in Ukr.).
  18. Kastels M. The information age: economy, society and culture. Trasnl. from Eng., ed. by O. I. Shkaratan. Moscow, GU VSHE, 2000: 606 (in Russ.).
  19. Kovin V. S. Gnostly regionalism: the case of Ukraine. Vestnik Permskogo un-ta. Politologiya, 2020: 14(1): 54–66 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.17072/2218-1067-2020-1-54-66; EDN: YJSXYI.
  20. Kononov I. F. Donbas in ethno-cultural coordinates of Ukraine (sociological analysis): dis. … d-ra sociol. n. Lugansk, 2005: 473 (in Ukr.).
  21. Korolov G. O. Ukrainian federalism in the historical discourse (the 19th – early 20th centuries). Kiev, Institut istoriyi Ukrayini NAN Ukrayini, 2010: 150 (in Ukr.).
  22. Kosov G. V., Makovskaya D. V. Population of Ukraine in conditions of state transit: a retrospective analysis. KANT: Social science & Humanities, 2024: 1(17): 67–75 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.24923/2305-8757.2024-17.8; EDN: EHOUNT.
  23. Kosov G. V., Makovskaya D. V. On the issue of the methodology of spatial differentiation of Ukraine in the context of dysfunctionalism and the phenomenon of "thirty years of amorphous integrity". KANT: Social science & Humanities, 2024: №1(17): 56–66 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.24923/2305-8757.2024-17.7; EDN: CXLOID.
  24. Kochan N. I. Religious situation in Ukraine: regional aspect. Sbornik nauchnyh rabot. Kamenec-Podolskij nac. un-t im. I. Ogienko, 2010: 1: 197–208 (in Ukr.).
  25. Kuromiya G. Donbas pomizh Ukrayinoyu ta Rosiyeyu: pozanacionalna identichnist? [Donbas between Ukraine and Russia: extra-national identity?] Globalizaciya. Regionalizaciya. Regionalna politika. Hrestomatiya z suchasnoyi zarubizhnoyi sociologiyi regioniv, Lugansk, 2002: 541–554 (in Ukr.).
  26. Kurylev K. P. Determinating factors of permanent instability in Ukraine. Postsovetskie issledovaniya, 2018: 1: 20–30 (in Russ.). EDN: XRPPJJ.
  27. Lipset S. M., Rokkan S. Cleavage Structures, Party System and Voter Alignment. Partii i vybory: Hrestomatiya [Parties and Elections: A Reader]. Ed. by N. V. Anohina, E. Yu. Meleshkina. Ch.1. Moscow, INION, 2004: 47–76 (in Russ.). EDN: NCUNUL.
  28. Melnichuk S. V. The origin and characteristics of regional polarization in the foreign policy orientations of the population of Ukraine. Uchenye zapiski KFU im. V. I. Vernadskogo. Filosofiya. Politologiya. Kulturologiya, 2023: 2: 116–127 (in Russ.). EDN: FXTNEI.
  29. Miller A. I. National identity in Ukraine: history and policy. Rossiya v globalnoj politike, 2022: 20: 4: 46–65 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.31278/1810-6439-2022-20-4-46-65; EDN: JKBXGA.
  30. Mchedlov M. P. Obshie voprosy religioznoj identichnosti: k postanovke problemy, usloviya ee obektivnogo analiza [General issues of religious identity: towards the formulation of the problem, conditions for its objective analysis]. Religiya v samosoznanii naroda (religioznyj faktor v identifikacionnyh processah) [Religion in the self-awareness of the people (religious factor in identification processes)]. Ed. by M. P. Mchedlov. Moscow, IS RAN, 2008: 13–33 (in Russ.).
  31. Nagorna L. P. Regional identity: ukrainian context. Kiev, IPiEND іmenі І. F. Kurasa NAN Ukraїni, 2008: 405 (in Ukr.).
  32. Naumov A. O., Naumova A. Yu. The problem of regional identity as a factor in the socio-political crisis in Ukraine in 2004. Izvestiya AltGU, 2021: 3(119): 54–60 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.14258/izvasu(2021)3-07; EDN: USCKKV.
  33. Panina N. V. Factors of national identity, tolerance, xenophobia, and anti-semitism in the present-day Ukraine. Vestnik obshestvennogo mneniya. Dannye. Analiz. Diskussii, 2006: 1 (81): 26–38 (in Russ.).
  34. Pahomenko S. P. Identity faktor in terms of Ukrainian crisis (on the example of Donbass region). Visnik Mariupolskogo derzh. un-tu. Ser.: Istoriya. Politologiya, 2015: 12: 246–253 (in Ukr.).
  35. Pelagesha N. Ye. Transformation of the Ukrainian national identity under conditions of globalization: avtoref. dis... kand. polit. n. Kiev, 2009: 26 (in Ukr.).
  36. Politichni problemi suchasnoyi Ukrayini. Analitichni dopovidi Institutu politichnih i etnonacionalnih doslidzhen im. I. F. Kurasa NAN Ukrayini [Political problems of modern Ukraine. Analytical reports of the Institute of Political and Ethnonational Studies named after I. F. Kuras NAS of Ukraine]. Kiev, IPIEND, 2012: 600 (in Ukr.).
  37. Rating Monitoring, 26th wave: Rating of the friendship of countries (February 10-11, 2024). Accessed 16.06.2024. URL: https://ratinggroup.ua/ru/research/ukraine/rejting-monitoring-26-ta-hvilya-ocinka-druzhnosti-krayin-10-11-lyutogo-2024.html (in Ukr.).
  38. Rogatin V. N. Persecution of Orthodoxy in Ukraine in 2014-2016. Moscow, RISI, FIV, 2017: 224 (in Russ.).
  39. Rogatin V. P. Transformaciya roli subnacionalnih regioniv u suchasnih politichnih procesah [Transformation of the role of subnational regions in modern political processes]: avtoref. dis... kand. polit. n. Simferopol, 2007: 20 (in Ukr.).
  40. Ryabchuk M. Yu. «Syak-tak, abiyak»: dvadcyat rokiv postkomunistichnoyi transformaciyi v Ukrayini ["One way or another": twenty years of post-communist transformation in Ukraine]. In Ukrayina. Procesi naciotvorennya. Kiev, K.I.S., 2011: 381–396 (in Ukr.).
  41. The Seventeenth National Poll: Identity. Patriotism. Values (August 17-18, 2022). Accessed 16.06.2024. URL: https://ratinggroup.ua/ru/research/ukraine/s_mnadcyate_zagalnonac_onalne_opituvannya_dentichn_st_patr_otizm_c_nnost_17-18_serpnya_2022.html (in Ukr.).
  42. Sereda V., Sudin D. Lviv’yanin – okrema identichnist chi prosto propiska [A Lvivian is a separate identity or just a residence permit]. Visnik HNU im. V. N. Karazina. Ser. «Sociologichni doslidzhennya suchasnogo suspilstva: metodologiya, teoriya, metodi», 2008: 795: 94–98 (in Ukr.).
  43. Sereda V. V. Regionalni vimiri ukrayinskogo sociumu: istorichne minule i nacionalni identichnosti [Regional dimensions of Ukrainian society: historical past and national identities]. Agora. Ukrayina – regionalnij vimir, 2006: 3: 29–41 (in Ukr.).
  44. Sereda V. V. Regional differences in historical identities and their impact on the formation of current political orientations in Ukraine: Avtoref. dis... kand. sociol. n. Kiev, 2006: 22 (in Ukr.).
  45. Stepiko M. T. Ukrayinska identichnist: fenomen i zasadi formuvannya [Ukrainian identity: phenomenon and principles of formation]. Kiev, NISD, 2011: 336 (in Ukr.).
  46. Tomajchuk L. V. Regionalism and regional identity in modern Ukraine. POLITEKS, 2013: 9: 1: 252–263 (in Russ.). EDN: RVOLQP.
  47. Fadeeva L. A. From social chronotope to political myth: Ukrainian case. Vestnik RUDN. Ser.: Politologiya, 2023: 25: 1: 150–162 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.22363/2313-1438-2023-25-1-150-162; EDN: FRYLMA.
  48. Halij I. A. Modern russian borderland: general characteristics. Vestnik instituta sotziologii, 2014: 4(11): 23–33 (in Russ.). EDN: RFUMXG.
  49. Hantington S. The clash of civilizations and the remaking of world order. Transl. from Engl. by T. Velimeeva, Yu. Novikova. Moscow, AST, 2003: 603 (in Russ.).
  50. Chernish N., Malanchuk O. Сomparative analysis of identities in L’viv and Donetsk (1994-2004). Accessed 15.06.2024. URL: https://uamoderna.com/images/archiv/12_2/5_UM_12_2_Statti_Chernysh_Malanchuk.pdf (in Ukr.).
  51. Shlihta I. V. Obraz vneshnego vraga v sochineniyah Dmitriya Doncova 1921–1939 godov [The image of the enemy in the works by D. Dontsov in 1921-1939]. Intelligenciya i vlast, 2013: 28: 142–152 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.17223/18572685/50/7.
  52. How do Ukrainians see relations between Ukraine and Russia and what associations do Ukrainians have with Russia and ordinary Russians. Accessed 20.07.2024. URL: https://www.kiis.com.ua/?lang=rus&cat=reports&id=1420&page=2&t=13 (in Ukr.).
  53. Barrington L. W., Herron E. S. One Ukraine or many? Regionalism in Ukraine and its political consequences. Nationalities Papers, 2004: 32: 1: 53–86 DOI: 10.1080/0090599042000186179.
  54. Giddens A. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1991: 247.
  55. Identities and Regionalism. Accessed 14.06.2024. URL: https://www.uaregio.org/en/surveys/data-visualisations/survey-infographics/identities/.
  56. Kulyk V. Ukrainian Identity in Time of War: More Salient and Radical. Accessed 16.06.2024. URL: https://www.iwm.at/publication/iwmpost-article/ukrainian-identity-in-time-of-war-more-salient-and-radical.
  57. Kuzio T. Identity and nation-building in Ukraine: Defining the «Other». Ethnicities, 2001: 1: 3: 343–365. DOI: 10.1177/146879680100100304.
  58. Kuzio T. National identity and history writing in Ukraine. Nationalities Papers, 2006: 34: 4: 407–427. DOI: 10.1080/00905990600842080.
  59. Kuzio T. Ukraine's relations with the west: disinterest, partnership, disillusionment. European Security, 2003: 12: 2: 21–44. DOI: 10.1080/09662830412331308046.
  60. Lewicka M. Regionalne zroznicowanie poczucia tozsamosci: porownanie Polski i Ukrainy [Regional Differentiation of Identity: Comparison of Poland and Ukraine]. Studia Regionalne i Lokalne, 2006: 1(23): 5–35 (in Pol).
  61. Shulman S. The Cultural Foundations of Ukrainian National Identity. Europe-Asia Studies, 2004: 56: 1: 35–56. DOI: 10.1080/0966813032000161437.
  62. Survey infographics. Historical memory. Accessed 14.06.2024. URL: https://www.uaregio.org/en/surveys/data-visualisations/survey-infographics/historical-memory/
  63. Voronovici A. Internationalist Separatism and the Political Use of “Historical Statehood” in the Unrecognized Republics of Transnistria and Donbass. Problems of Post-Communism, 2020: 67: 3: 288–302. DOI: 10.1080/10758216.2019.1594918.